Jan 12, 2014

Mr Z's 2013 Golf Year Review

When my golf year began on April 7th at Ruffled Feathers near my home in Lemont, I had hopes of playing 1,000 holes in 2013, but when I sank my last putt on November 21st at Oyster Reef on Hilton Head Island, the final tally was "only" 827.  This included 29 different courses locally, including 11 that I had never set foot on previously, plus 54 holes in Texas (north of Dallas) in April, 54 holes in May at Eagle Ridge in Galena, and 36 holes in South Carolina to close the year.  I was able to tour some of the best courses the Windy City has to offer, and I had a few good shots interspersed with all the shanks and slices that are common to a 20 handicapper's game (my CDGA handicap was actually 16.0 at the end of the year, close enough).

I checked off 9 of the 13 tracks on my "Courses to Play" list, missing out on Mistwood, Willow Crest, Deerfield and Shepherd's Crook, but I did get to ThunderHawk and Schaumburg, two superb facilities left over from the 2012 list.  Here are the 10 that delivered the best total golf experiences from 2013:

ThunderHawk (Beach Park) - This Robert Trent Jones Jr design near the Wisconsin border was a thrilling mix of woods and wetlands, with higher end amenities that belie its Lake County Forest Preserve roots.  Weekend green fees w/cart in the mid $80's might be a strain to some budgets, but twilight rates are extremely reasonable and this is one of the best courses I've played in the Windy City and definitely worth the money and the drive.

Village Links of Glen Ellyn - One of the courses that I look forward to playing each year, the Village Links is a beautiful parkland layout with the just the right spacing to make it great for walkers.  I grabbed 3 friends and we took advantage of the $100 Happy Hour special, and $25 each to walk the Village links on a pleasant Sunday afternoon in early May was the best bargain of 2013.  The new clubhouse and driving range only adds to the overall excellent experience.

Orchard Valley (Aurora) - An old favorite that I hadn't visited for several years, this Ken Kavanaugh design uses imaginative and extensive bunkering and the lake that runs through the property to wondrous effect.  Rumors of substandard conditions were not apparent on my visit Memorial Day weekend.

Golf Club of Illinois (Algonquin) - An early prairie links style track in northwest suburbia was considerably softened by the removal of acres of fescue, but there is still plenty of challenge at this par 71 layout.  Possibly the best greens I played in 2013, the under $60 green fees and 10 minute tee time intervals are major pluses.

Schaumburg GC - It took me 2 summers to play all 27 holes at SGC, but the wait was worth it, as the three nines (Players, Tournament, Baer) are equally appealing, and the course is hillier than one would guess from the entrance on Roselle Road.  10 minute playing intervals plus a 55 and over senior rate are added bonuses.

Seven Bridges (Woodridge) - Few courses in the Windy City rival the scenery at this high end parkland course, and the 74.6 / 144 rating / slope from the tips makes this a supreme challenge.  The reduced spring and fall rates are the ideal time to play and avoid the $100+ green fees (we paid $47 in October on a Saturday afternoon with the age 55 senior discount).

Pottawatomie (St. Charles) - Full length 9 hole course on the eastern bank of the the Fox River was originally designed by Robert Trent Jones Sr in the late 1930's, then meticulously updated by local architect Greg Martin a few years ago.  Smallish footprint (42 acres) is a bit tight in spots, but none the less one of the better 2 hours you can spend golfing in the far west 'burbs.

Harborside Port (Chicago) - Wind swept links on the shore of Lake Calumet in south Chicago costs a pretty penny ($100+ with the city amusement tax) but the final 3 holes along the water are truly amazing.  The starter told us we're as close to Scotland as you'll find in metro Chicago, and he might just be correct.  Spring and fall savings have been instituted since Billy Casper golf took over management, softening the blow on the pocketbook.

Hilldale (Hoffman Estates) - The only 18 hole Windy City track with RTJ Sr's name attached, this par 71 layout is on the short side (6,400 yds) by modern standards, but has plenty of chops with mature trees, rolling hills and quick, sloping greens.  Extremely reasonable green fees added to 10 minute tee times help negate a few rough edges and the subdivision routing.

Prairie Isle (Prairie Grove) - Over shadowed by its more acclaimed neighbors in Cary (Chalet Hills and Foxford Hills), Prairie Isle was a major surprise as the elevated tees and tight, tree lined fairways provides an aesthetically pleasing and very playable course. The 12th and 13th holes at the far end of the property that run up and over a ridge are beauties.  Take advantage of the $27 walk / $44 ride weekday rate.

Here are the other fine public facilities in the Windy City where I chased the ball (mostly yellow Noodles) in 2013:  Ruffled Feathers (Lemont), Bonnie Brook (Waukegan), Old Oak (Homer Glen), Wedgewood and Inwood (Joliet), Lincoln Oaks (Crete), Odyssey (Tinley Park), Naperbrook (Plainfield), White Pines West (Bensenville), Village Greens of Woodridge, Broken Arrow (Lockport), Sanctuary (New Lenox), Gleneagles Red and White (Lemont), Wing Park (Elgin), Woodbine (Homer Glen) and the recently rejuvenated Fox Run (Elk Grove) and soon to be redesigned Oak Meadows (Wooddale).

Special mention goes to Stonebridge CC in Aurora, which I was invited to play back in July.  One time home to the LPGA and Senior tours, Stonebridge is a modern prairie / parkland hybrid designed by Tom Fazio, and I had a thoroughly enjoyable time (except for the 5 putts I took on the crazily sloped 8th green), and it would definitely be in my top 10 list if open to the public.
********************
Although I've never professed to be an expert on golf course design, I know when a hole is aesthetically appealing and strikes the right balance between fairness and challenge.  I'm sure that other golfers, if given the same group to pick from, may choose a completely different list, but here are my favorite 18 out of the 486 holes I played locally last year, the ones that made the biggest impression on me in 2013:

Par 5's

ThunderHawk 16th Hole 578 yards - The tee shot is slightly uphill through mature trees, but it's what you see at the top of the ridge that's amazing, as the prairie laden mounds to the left and the lake to the right, with the wide green tucked behind the water and the woods in the background, provides a spectacular view.

Wing Park 6th Hole 571 yards - The first 5 holes at this history rich course in Elgin (oldest 9 hole muni in Illinois) does not prepare you for the 6th.  The downhill tee shot disappears with OB right and a pond out of sight (but not out of range for longer drivers) to the left.  The hole continues past the water with a steady rise through the woods to a green that is comfortably nestled in an amphitheatre of mature trees, an excellent parkland hole.

Wedgewood 2nd Hole 563 yards - The tee shot is innocent enough with only water far off to the left, but a turn to the right exposes stands of mature trees bordering both sides of the slightly downhill fairway, with the back to front sloping green blocked by several particularly large hardwoods on the left.

Hilldale 2nd Hole 550 yards - From the tee tucked back in the woods, the fairway moves to the right and away from the first pond, then shifts slightly left as the second pond comes into play the last 125 yards.  The view from the elevated 3rd tee overlooking this hole is special.

Par 4's

Schaumburg GC (Players) 6th Hole 440 yards - Tight drive through evergreens left and mature hardwoods right bordering Roselle Road heads due south, and the approach will test your nerves as water / wetlands bisects the fairway from right to left and curls around the back of the green.  Four sand traps guard the putting surface should you make it safely over the hazard, an intimidating and beautiful hole.

Village Links of Glen Ellyn 14th Hole 429 yards - Inspiring view off the tee with a huge beach style bunker bordering the pond on the right and 2 more traps at the base of the mounds on the left, with the fairway climbing to an elusive, narrow green.

Golf Club of Illinois 12th Hole 393 yards - This hole follows the signature 678 yard monster at GCI, but I enjoyed it so much more.  A pond lurks off to the left, but it's the bunkers built into a side hill on the far edge of the water that adds to the visual interest and challenge.  Thick woods border the OB to the right, and the green is severely tiered with prairie in all directions.

Prairie Isle 13th Hole 408 yards - The drive needs to travel 250 yards to reach the top of a steep hill, then it's up and over down to the green.  Dramatic hole at the far edge of a very nice layout was a stunning surprise.

Pottawatomie 9th hole 420 yards - Plantings enhance the tee area with OB left, with a turn left the last 100 yards to an elevated green with traps studded liberally into the hill below.  A fitting end to an excellent 9 hole track.

Naperbrook 13th Hole 406 yards - A stand of old growth trees guard the right side, and the green teeters on the edge of a pond that stretches back 100 yards on the left.  Two humps on the right half makes for several treacherous pin placements on the huge putting surface.

Bonnie Brook 11th hole 306 yards - An excellent short par 4 that might be reachable from the elevated tee, but the water that crosses halfway out and widens up the left side, the large fairway trap 75 yards short of the green on the right, and the 3 additional traps greenside adequately protects par.

Harborside (Port) 17th Hole 407 yards - This dogleg left sits on the north shore of Lake Calumet and epitomizes the stark beauty of Harborside.  A beach worth of sand lies at the bend and merges into the water to capture any offline attempts to cut the turn, and extrication from the waste area can be painful.  The ever present prairie fringes the hazard up to the green.

Seven Bridges 14th Hole 427 yards - The DuPage River plays havoc on the back nine at Seven Bridges, and it's the main feature on 14, as it flows straight through the dogleg.  The option to play over the river off the tee is available, but a forecaddie would be advisable to help find your ball.  The green sports an unusual front to back slope.

Inwood 15th Hole 396 yards - This dogleg left par 4 stood out on my first tour of this Joliet Park District course.  Water crosses the fairway twice, the 2nd time about 75 yards short of the elevated green.  Woods on the left will block the approach if you're not positioned properly off the tee.  Two big traps flank each side of the putting surface on this very good hole.

Par 3's

ThunderHawk 17th Hole 182 yards - The tee box is hidden back in the woods, with the large green to the left of the lake shared with the par five 16th.  Prairie and wildflower covered hills provide a gorgeous and hazardous backdrop.  These were the 2 best consecutive holes I played in 2013.

Orchard Valley 17th Hole 208 yards - This hole hugs the edge of the lake so any shots pushed right are gone, and a sprawling trap flanks the left side of the long, narrow and sloping green.

Ruffled Feathers 3rd Hole 193 yards - Pete Dye became famous by pushing the limits of golf course architecture, and the 3rd hole at Ruffled Feathers (his only design in the Windy City area) fits this model as the green seems to disappear into the water hazard.  If your ball somehow manages to find the strip of land between the two, be careful not to fall in the pond.

Gleneagles (Red) 16th Hole 166 yards - The 16th hole was updated a number of years ago at this 90 year old facility in Lemont.  The wide, shallow green is perched atop a plateau above the water hazard, with thick rough and the woods tight behind, a difficult target to find, especially when into the westerly breeze.

Total "Course" - 7,043 yards Par 72
********************
A main part of the experience of a day on the course for me is the recap after the round, a chance to share a drink, some food and a few laughs with your playing partners.  I always try to find a local establishment to top off the day and experience some of the flavor of the area.  Here are my favorite after golf stops from last year:

The Shanty - Wadsworth (after ThunderHawk) - Rustic roadside diner is known for its seafood, but the burgers were stellar, too.  Featured on Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives and a number of other local shows, this was the perfect finish to a great round (aesthetically, not score wise) at ThunderHawk.  www.theshantyrestaurant.com

Alfie's Inn - Glen Ellyn (after Village Links) - Famous for their burgers and ribs, though I'm partial to the lean corned beef on the regal Reuben sandwich at this legendary west suburban eatery.  www.alfiesinn.com

Quonset Pizza - Waukegan (after Bonnie Brook) - Being housed in an old quonset hut is totally unique, and the food was pretty good, too.  Didn't have time for a pizza, but the Meatball sandwich was quite tasty.  The 50's diners motif definitely harkens back to a bygone era.  www.quonsetpizza.com

Ed & Joe's - Tinley Park (after Odyssey) - Located on Oak Park Avenue in old Tinley Park, this old school pizza parlor features excellent pies, sandwiches and salads in a comfortable setting just a few miles north of the Odyssey.  www.ednjoes.com

Kief's Reef - McHenry (after Prairie Isle) - Eclectic restaurant & bar on the Fox River has good food and a cool vibe, and is a haven for motorcyclists in the summer.  Just down the street from Prairie Isle on Route 176...  https://www.facebook.com/kiefs.reef

Cousin Tony's backyard in Elgin (after Wing Park) - Hand crafted burgers on the grill can't be beat!  Unfortunately, not open to the public... 

If you prefer to stay and utilize the "19th hole" at the course, the view from the clubhouse at Harborside overlooking the 18th hole of the Port course is hard to beat.  Other top 19th hole views from 2013 included the outdoor patios at Orchard Valley and the Village Greens of Woodridge, overlooking the 18th holes at each course, great places to enjoy a cold one after the round.

********************
I'm all about the "deal", and as I previously mentioned, the $25 I paid to walk the Village Links of Glen Ellyn was my best of 2013.  Here are some of the other bargains I uncovered last year:

$30.50 w/cart at the Golf Club of Illinois on  a Sunday afternoon in September using a 2 for 1 special with the Chicago Golf Pass

$35 w/cart at Schaumburg GC, booked on their website as an early bird special on the Friday morning of the 4th of July weekend

$30 w/cart at Hilldale on a Monday in August at noon (regular rate)

$19 w/cart at Lincoln Oaks on a weekday afternoon as part of a special offered at the Tinley Golf Expo (but the rates are always reasonable here)

$27 w/cart at the Sanctuary, weekend afternoon fall rate

$33 w/cart at Bonnie Brook, weekend afternoon online fall special
********************
What were my most memorable shots from 2013?  Not a lot to pick from, but I do recall making a winding 50 foot putt at the long par three 13th hole at Wedgewood (to save a bogey).  I was also lying 3 in a sand trap about 125 yards from the green and staring at triple bogey on the fabulous par five 16th at ThunderHawk, but I pulled a rabbit out of the hat and hit an 8 iron to within 10 feet...only to miss the par putt and settle for bogey.  But my best shot(s) was on the short 15th hole at Seven Bridges.  The ball mark from my tee shot was a foot away from the pin, and the slick downhill 15 footer found the bottom for a well earned birdie. 

On the very next hole, the chip shot of one of my playing partners from the edge of the green was a bit off line and struck my ball, which was about 7 feet from the pin...and ricocheted it right into the cup!  Can't recall ever seeing that happen before, but it was a totally unusual and appropriate ending to an amazing golf year on the public links of the Windy City!

No comments:

Post a Comment

About This Site

I am a life long Chicagoan and an avid golfer (or as much as my wife will let me!). And I am also a closet journalist who needed an outlet, so I decided to write reviews of the golf courses that I've played over the years in Chicago. Plus I've added detailed information on each course to help my fellow public golfers find the ones that best fits their skill level and budgets. So, read the reviews and use the comments to either give me a big "thumbs up" or tell me I'm full of crap, check out the courses and other pages, and let me know what you think... Mr Z